
I don't think fantasy books generally adapt well to screen. There's always way too much material to cram into a two- or three-hour block of time, and no amount of CGI can substitute for what the human imagination creates in response to the words on a page.
The Golden Compass, based on the first book in Philip Pullman's trilogy
His Dark Materials, is no exception to the rule. Everything feels abbreviated and rushed -- the film is less than two hours long, absurdly short for a fantasy piece. And that isn't the only irritating thing about it. These fantasy adaptations are starting to feel rather cookie-cutter and perfunctory. The special effects here are competent but by no means original, and the score is forgettable.
Nevertheless: despite the breakneck pace and the cliched cinematography, I have to say I enjoyed watching
Golden Compass. Maybe that's because, this time, I didn't read the book before seeing the movie. I could tell things were being left out, but I didn't know exactly what was missing at each moment. So I was able to appreciate the movie for what it is: a teaser-trailer for an unusually interesting book. Think of it that way, and you can take its rushing in stride.
The story in a nutshell is as follows: in a universe parallel to our own, Oxford University -- oops, I mean, Jordan College -- and the Catholic Church -- oops, I mean, the Magisterium -- find themselves at odds with one another. The independent thinkers at Jordan want to find out the truth about the universe. The Magisterium wants, at all costs, to keep people from finding out the truth. Caught in the middle of this struggle is Lyra, aka "The Child," who in this movie begins her journey toward breaking the chokehold that the evil Magisterium has on the world. Her first task: find a way to thwart a plot by the Magisterium to separate children from their daemons, aka their souls, which exist outside their bodies in the form of animal companions.
The sheer originality of its fantasy world is one of
Golden Compass's biggest strengths, but of course it owes this to the book on which it's based, and not to anything the filmmakers did. Thus, the movie definitely made me want to read the books, which I guess is the definition of a successful trailer. I'm hooked. I'm intrigued by the power of Pullman's imagination, and I want to see, on paper, how nuanced (or not) is his handling of the religious and philosophical themes he's playing with. He tosses around concepts like authority and free will; I want to see how well he really understands them. And I want to see the movie's bare-bones outline of the plot filled in with all its original detail.
Also strong in this movie is the acting, especially Nicole Kidman as a chillingly malign Mrs. Coulter. Ian McKellen, too, is delightful as the voice of the polar bear Iorek. One expects such convincing intensity from mature A-listers like Kidman and McKellen, but the pleasant surprise in
Golden Compass is newcomer Dakota Blue Richards as Lyra. She is already a better actress than any of the
Harry Potter kids will ever be: there is a self-possession and authority to her performance that gives the character credibility, and she does defiance frighteningly well. Her eyes really do burn when she's angry. I had no difficulty believing that this was a child with the strength of will to go to hell and back; I'd probably follow her there, too. As child actresses go, she's close to the level of Ivana Baquero (from
Pan's Labyrinth), though her performance is not quite as effortless.
As far as Pullman's atheism goes: I don't feel I'm equipped to comment on that until I've read the books, which I plan to do very soon. If they are, as seems to be the general consensus, an atheist allegory much as the
Chronicles of Narnia are a Christian allegory, then I can't see why Christian parents would give them to their children to read, any more than I can see why atheist parents would give their children Narnia to read. Allegory is meant to provide a set of images that make an abstract belief system accessible to the imagination. It's more overtly pedagogical in intent than most art forms are (or should be). So, why you'd want to provide your child with a set of images designed to reinforce a belief system with which you do not agree, I'm just not sure. As for children old enough to engage with the ideas being presented and discuss them intelligently, well, that might be another story. I'll just have to wait and make up my mind when I've read the books.
But there is one point, at least, on which I am in perfect agreement with
The Golden Compass's worldview: truth matters. Many brave men and women have lived and died for it...and with good reason.
Labels: Movie Reviews